Interesting to see a story developed around a protagonist who is angry, self-pitying and cowardly, but hard to stay interested, as the "Quest" drags on rather unremarkably, and the only other character who held my interest was soon left behind. I also had hope that the reality vs. dream theme would be better developed, but that just sort of fizzled at the end, along with the quest.
— Alberto Manguel, A History of Reading (via invisiblestories)
I'm pretty sure there was a story there somewhere, but it was mostly obscured by an unedited regurgitation of words.
The real mystery in the book, how and why the city was split, is never resolved. Weak characterization makes it even more painful.
Not as well-developed as Shadow of the Wind or Angel's Game, but has good backstory of the characters from those two novels.